Blogs

The problem: you only get one night, and “it exists” isn’t the same as “it’s good”

I’ve done the classic travel mistake. You land in a new city, you have one free evening, and you think, “cool, i’ll find a local game store and jam some Commander.”

Then you show up and it’s:

• a tiny shop with no play space
• a closed door because the hours were wrong
• Yu-Gi-Oh night (which is fine, unless you brought a deck box and optimism)
• a room full of regulars who are nice, but not in the mood to adopt a stranger

So the goal isn’t “find an LGS.” The goal is “find the right LGS for the kind of night you want.”

Here’s a quick, reliable way to do that using the tools that actually work: Wizards’ locator, Google Maps, local Discords, and Reddit.

Step 1: Start with the Wizards Store & Event Locator (it’s the fastest filter)

If you play Magic: The Gathering, the Wizards Store & Event Locator is your best starting point. Not because it’s perfect, but because it answers the only question that matters first:

“Is Magic happening there when i’m free?”

Use it in two ways:

1. Search for stores near where you’re staying.
   This gives you a shortlist of places that are at least on Wizards’ radar (usually WPN stores).
2. Search for events on the specific night you have available.
   If it’s Friday, look for Friday Night Magic. If it’s a random Tuesday, look for Commander night or open play events.

A store can be amazing, but if the only Magic event is on Thursday and you fly out Wednesday morning, it doesn’t matter.

One extra tip: when you open a store listing, look for anything that signals the store actively runs organized play. A real event calendar beats a vague “we host Magic” vibe every time.

Step 2: Cross-check the store on Google Maps (hours, photos, and the “review tells”)

Once you have 3–6 candidates, jump to Google Maps. This is where you figure out if the store is a place you’ll actually enjoy sitting in for three hours.

Check the basics first

• Hours: are they open when you need them to be open?
• Location: is it walkable from your hotel, or does it require a 25-minute rideshare each way?
• Parking / transit: you don’t want to be stressed before you even shuffle.

Then look at photos like you’re scouting a venue

Photos are underrated. They tell you things reviews don’t.

Look for:

• Play space: actual tables, not one lonely folding table in a corner
• Lighting: dim dungeon lighting sounds romantic until you’re trying to read board states
• Seating: chairs that look like they’ve seen war are a warning sign
• Crowd size: a packed room can be fun… or miserable, depending on your mood
• Cleanliness: you can usually tell

If a store has zero photos of play space, it doesn’t automatically mean it’s bad. But it does mean you need more proof before you commit your only free night.

Read reviews, but read the right parts

Overall star rating is not the point. You’re not buying a blender.

Instead, skim reviews for keywords that matter for an MTG night:

• “Commander night”
• “friendly”
• “welcoming”
• “regulars”
• “tournament”
• “pairings”
• “judge”
• “pricing” (for singles, entry fees, snacks)

And pay attention to patterns. One person having a weird day? Whatever. Ten people mentioning the same problem? That’s a signal.

Also, look at how recent the feedback is. Stores change fast. Owners change. Staff changes. Communities change.

Step 3: Find the local chatter (Discord is where the real answers live)

If you want the truth quickly, find the community’s group chat. In a lot of areas, that’s Discord.

Many stores link their Discord in one of these places:

• their website
• their Google listing
• their Instagram bio
• their Facebook page
• a pinned post in local MTG groups

What you’re looking for is simple: evidence of active life.

Signs the Discord is alive:

• recent messages (today or yesterday, not three months ago)
• channels for “Commander,” “LFG,” or “events”
• people asking “any pods tonight?” and getting responses
• store staff posting event reminders

If you join, don’t overthink your intro. A short message works:

“Hey! I’m in town for work and free tonight. Do people usually get Commander pods going on Tuesdays?”

You’ll learn more from two replies than from 40 Google reviews.

And if the Discord is dead or hard to find, that’s not a deal-breaker. It just means you should lean harder on the next step.

Step 4: Use Reddit like a local (search first, then ask one clean question)

Reddit is great for travel MTG… if you use it right.

Search before posting

Try searches like:

• “best LGS in [city] commander”
• “[city] MTG Friday Night Magic”
• “[neighborhood] game store commander”

A lot of cities have the same question asked every few months, and the answers don’t change that quickly.

If you post, make it easy to answer

Bad post: “any good stores?”
Good post: “In [city] near [area]. Free Thursday night. Looking for casual Commander pods. Where should i go?”

That one sentence tells people:

• where you’ll be
• when you’re available
• what kind of Magic you want
• what “good” means to you

You’ll also sometimes get useful warnings like, “that store is fine, but Thursday is Modern night and Commander doesn’t fire.”

That’s exactly the kind of info that saves a night.

Step 5: The “good LGS” checklist (what matters when you’re a visitor)

Here’s what i look for when i’m trying to avoid a wasted trip across town.

Green flags

• Clear event schedule (posted somewhere and matches reality)
• “New players welcome” energy (people mention it in reviews or chats)
• Staff who answer questions (even a quick “yep, Commander starts at 6”)
• Enough space that you won’t feel like you’re borrowing someone’s chair
• Pods form naturally (reviews mention open play, pick-up games, regular Commander nights)

Yellow flags (not bad, just “verify first”)

• A very competitive reputation if you’re hoping for a relaxed night
• A store that’s mostly a retail shop with minimal play space
• Mixed reviews on crowd behavior (could be one salty regular, could be real)
• No obvious Commander night but they claim “casual play happens”

Yellow flags just mean: message someone, call the shop, or ask in Discord before you commit.

Red flags

• “They don’t honor their posted hours” (it happens)
• Repeated complaints about harassment, hygiene, or staff behavior
• Events that “never fire” (you show up and it’s three people staring at binders)
• No way to contact them that gets a response (website form into the void)

The 15-minute process when you’re tired, hungry, and just want to play

If you want the shortest version, do this:

1. Wizards locator: find 5 stores near you that list MTG events.
2. Google Maps: cut it to 2–3 based on hours + photos + review patterns.
3. Discord/IG/FB: check if people are actively playing this week.
4. If still unsure: call the store and ask one question:
   “Do you usually get Commander pods on [night] around [time]?”

That’s it. You’re not writing a dissertation. You’re trying to have a good night.

Conclusion: “good” is the store that matches your night

The best LGS in a city might be the wrong store for you on the one night you’re free. So don’t chase “best.” Chase “best fit.”

Use the Wizards locator to make sure Magic is actually happening. Use Google Maps to judge the space and the vibe. Use Discord and Reddit to get the real, current scoop. Then pick the place that gives you the highest odds of sitting down, shuffling up, and playing a normal, fun game with humans you’ll probably never see again (in the best way).

And if you find a great spot, leave a helpful review. Future traveling nerds will thank you.